♪ ♪
High drama in low tides at Lake Mead this morning.
A shallow diver searching for hidden treasure
found more than what he bargained for,
deadly remains. Sir?
I'm here now with Jeremiah Beck, the diver.
Sir, what were you looking for down there
besides the shock of your life?
Oh, uh, buddies of mine have been finding
all kind of cool stuff since the lake dried up.
Mm.
Y'all waiting for an engraved invitation?
There are human remains down there.
Let's get to work.
What?
It's a child.
Go for Roby.
♪ ♪
Look, it's a dollar bill
in a sealed baggie.
Oh, look,
they doodled on it.
Little smiling little egg.
RAJAN: Yeah.
Little smiling little egg.
RAJAN: Yeah.
Whoa, look at that date.
1982.
ROBY: Hey, Greg.
(Transylvania accent): Dr. Roby. You rang? (laughs)
(chuckles) I get it. Count Sanders 'cause I asked you
to be on the "vampire shift." Yeah, you funny.
I vant to make you proud.
Yeah, yeah, yeah,
I know, I know.
(normal voice): Seriously, though, I'm happy
to pinch-hit for your nightshift supervisor.
Thank you. I thank you.
Claudia thanks you.
Her new little baby thanks you.
I think I can lose some sleep
over one new mother's maternity leave,
but I thought my reunion tour of duty
didn't start till tonight.
Okay, sorry to tap you early,
but I'm in the middle of a waking nightmare.
Let Count Sanders guess, body in a barrel.
Mm-hmm.
Rumor has it, it's an early '80s mob hit.
It's not a mob hit because the body belongs to a child,
and what I really need
is an anthropologist. You got one?
Let me grab my cape.
You've come to the right vampire.
Come on, Count.
You've come to the right vampire.
Come on, Count.
Well, hello.
Dr. Roby.
Oh, and you must be Dr. Hudson.
I'm Dr. Heather Chumani.
Thanks for coming on such short notice.
Someone show me a pelvic bone.
Boy, you guys did a nice job of setting this out here.
Thank you.
Mm...
Oh... poor girl.
It's a girl.
It's difficult to determine morphology of race,
but I do know that we're looking at a female child.
Based on the...
non-fusion of the basilar suture,
I'd say your girl was around eight to ten years old.
Hmm...
What's less certain is the cause
of this outer scrape,
the right side of the temple,
just above the orbital bone.
Antemortem or postmortem?
Neither, I think.
Antemortem or postmortem?
Neither, I think.
Probably perimortem, near time of death.
I don't know how long our Jane Doe
has been in that lake, but
based on the osteologic reaction to the temple, I'm thinking
whatever happened to her face
is the reason why she's in that barrel.
So, can you bring our little girl back to life?
All I need is a quiet work area.
I know just the place.
♪ ♪
There she is.
Maxine Roby,
meet our little Jane Doe.
ROBY: We have your face.
Now, all we need is your name.
♪ ♪
♪ Who... are you? ♪
♪ Who, who, who, who? ♪
♪ Who... are you? ♪
♪ Who, who, who, who? ♪
♪ I really wanna know ♪
♪ Who... are you? ♪
♪ Oh-oh-oh ♪
♪ Who... ♪
♪ Oh-oh-oh ♪
♪ Who... ♪
♪ Come on, tell me who are you, you, you ♪
♪ Are you! ♪
CHAVEZ: Can I ask you a question?
Yup.
How did the anthropologist determine her skin tone?
She didn't.
Uh, I mean, she's not translucent, so...
It's called "neutral palette technique."
When the race of a victim is unknown,
the forensic artists use a blend of all skin pigmentations.
Hmm. Makes sense.
We need an image that's as inclusive as possible.
Cast the widest net.
We want everyone giving this girl a careful look.
Yeah, I will. I will be there in an hour.
Let me call you back.
Uh, what's going on?
It'll come to you.
Oh...
Bryan's art thing. Damn it.
The gallery opening for his girlfriend.
We were, we were supposed to...
I know, I know. I'm sorry.
You don't have to apologize to me. I'm just the ex-husband.
I expect to be blown off.
Bryan, though...
What do you want me to tell him?
I'll talk to him.
I got to put out my own fires. Damn it.
I don't see any fires, but I do smell smoke.
You okay?
They found the remains of a child
in a barrel
at the bottom of Lake Mead.
It's a cold case. Gonna be a long week.
Hmm.
They all are.
Yeah.
I understand. Um...
Work comes first.
Yeah.
If you just so happen to get a break,
text me.
We can take Bry to lunch, make it up to him.
Thank you.
Yeah.
(sighs) Time?
37 seconds.
Texas Chainsaw Massacre fans would be impressed
by the way you wield that thing.
Well, I have been lumber-jacking since I left CSI.
Really? Oh.
No.
Really? Oh.
No.
I've been writing a book, but I do own several flannel shirts.
I've got to wonder, why so blue?
Hand me the scalpel and a Q-pack.
Yeah.
I'm gonna get this to trace.
Yeah.
I'm gonna get this to trace.
Wait.
What is that?
GREG: "Salt Mine Company"?
Salt Mine Company specializes in the obvious,
sodium production.
Our facility also manufactures
its own barrels for transport.
I think what you're looking for
is right here, model MHAZ.
Made of cold rolled steel.
We used them in the late '70s, early '80s.
That's when you switched to plastic?
Yeah.
Makes sense, given the weather and oxidation,
this rock salt becomes hygroscopic,
changes into liquid
and clumps... up...
You want a job here or something?
No, we just want to confirm.
This barrel did come from Salt Mine Co.?
Hon, I suspect you can read.
We ship all over the world.
That one with your body in it,
it could've come from Munich or Manhattan.
This one was dumped in Lake Mead, not the East River.
When did you start working here?
Started in '79. Why?
I want a roster of employees from back then.
Yeah, okay.
As if someone couldn't have stolen
the damn barrel.
You ever think that, uh, your kid in the can
might've been some parent's way of, uh,
getting rid of a problem?
I think this was some parent's worst nightmare.
Fellas, I got to go get
a missing girl's face out into the community,
and you got to get me that roster.
Or I'll be back.
Dr. Milton Hudson examining the skeletal remains
of an unidentified child,
presumed missing,
Jane Doe.
Full skeletal remains
came from a barrel discovered in Lake Mead.
Approximate height:
four feet, four inches tall.
Approximate weight: 60 to 70 pounds.
There are no irregular, identifying features.
Just who this little girl was, that remains...
ROBY: Unknown.
HUDSON: Capitate, hamate bones...
...nearly obliterated.
ROBY: Is that a gunshot wound?
HUDSON: Looks like.
Can't say which direction the shot was fired,
but the bullet hit the right wrist square.
Uh-huh.
Uh...
Perimortem is the theme of the day.
Looks like a clear, perforated hole right through the scapula.
Through and through.
Looks like.
Mm-hmm.
Bullet exited her back and just
kept on going.
It means that she was
probably shot at close range, right?
All of this damage could be explained by a single shot.
She's facing the shooter.
Mm-hmm.
She's facing the shooter.
Mm-hmm.
Put up a hand.
Okay.
Ah...
Damn it.
That means that it was the last thing she ever saw.
Okay. The blue substance
from the bottom of the barrel was
a combination of aluminum,
colored reflective and adhesive sheeting,
and paint.
Could be a million things.
But who knows, you can never count out
Locard's exchange principle.
Every contact...
Locard's exchange principle.
Every contact...
leaves a trace.
Leaves a trace.
Um, well, we can count out DNA.
I ran the clumps of wavy brown hair.
It's too degraded for a sample.
Greg, zero. Penny, zero.
Uh, Greg, zero. Penny, one.
The white Mary Janes are a youth size 5.
Patent leather.
My guess is
she might've been killed before or after church.
Sorry, you lost me at
"my guess."
Well...
There's a Sunday school patch on her shirt.
You sure that's what that is?
Every Sunday, my entire childhood.
I was an acolyte. I even taught Sunday school
for a few years.
Okay.
Penny, five. Greg, zero.
But these two rhinestone barrettes
could get me on the board.
This one is in perfect condition.
The metal on this one
is burnt and twisted.
Doesn't look like
corrosion from being underwater 40 years to me.
Hard to say what did it, though.
Whatever it was might've made the hole in this glove.
Here. Check out the photo of Jane Doe's right wrist.
Look at how the hole in the glove lines up
perfectly.
GREG: She was shot through the hand.
The bigger hole's in the back,
which means that's where the bullet exited.
It makes this a defensive wound.
I think this confirms a theory they had in the morgue,
probably a single shot fired.
Wow.
Penny, a zillion. Greg...
like, two.
CHAVEZ: I really appreciate you letting us pass out the flyers.
It's gonna be very helpful.
Of course, we're happy to help.
Is there a particular reason
Plymouth Baptist is on your list?
Longevity.
We're hitting every Vegas church
old enough to have Sunday school back in the '80s.
There's only a few of them left.
I'll say a prayer for you.
I'll never turn down one of those.
♪ ♪
FOLSOM: She's just at the end of the hall here.
RAQUEL: So, you're taking me to the captain?
FOLSOM: Yes, ma'am.
Person who makes decisions around here.
Yes, ma'am.
FOLSOM: Uh,
sorry, boss. This woman...
Mrs. Williams.
Raquel Williams.
Mrs. Williams is asking if...
Demanding.
To speak to you.
Uh-huh. Hello, Mrs. Williams. I am Maxine Roby.
I need to speak to the person in charge.
Okay, I-I... Thank you so much. Thank you
Mm-hmm.
Okay, I-I... Thank you so much. Thank you
Mm-hmm.
I am the person in charge.
I'm Maxine Roby. I am director of the crime lab.
So, you're the one?
You're responsible for this?
You have some information about our Jane Doe?
Never mind this damn flyer. Her name is Phoebe.
Phoebe Williams, not Jane Doe.
This dollar bill on her person?
That was money to buy a book.
Humpty Dumpty for her little cousin.
She was wearing white patent leather
church shoes for the Lord on Sunday.
How am I doing so far?
This...
...is Phoebe Williams.
Your child?
That's right.
I'm her mother.
Mrs. Williams, I am so sorry for your loss.
And our lab has gone to great lengths
to try to put a face to your daughter.
You certainly did that.
And when the race of a victim is unknown,
our standard operating procedure...
I may not be in good health, Dr. Roby,
but my mind is just fine.
I know why you did what you did. I just don't like it.
You made my girl look like
she's someone else, and then you put
that face everywhere.
That flyer is the reason we found you.
That flyer makes us one step closer
to finding out what happened to your daughter.
And I know you're upset...
No, don't. Don't.
I know...
Don't tell me how I feel.
You don't know how I feel.
You haven't lived with the loss of your baby for...
...41...
...years.
You're right. I have not.
1982.
We were shot at in cold blood in the middle of the street.
My girl's body was taken.
The police...
wrote their damn report
with a dull pencil on a cocktail napkin.
My phone never rang.
They didn't care about her back then.
They didn't care. Sorry for your loss,
my ass!
Mrs. Williams.
Mrs. Williams, don't walk out on me.
Excuse me.
Mrs. Williams, do not walk out on me.
Mrs. Williams, you walk out on me, you walk out on Phoebe.
"They" is me now, Mrs. Williams.
Phoebe is on my watch.
And my watch does not need winding.
And I will do everything, ma'am.
Everything within my power to find the people
that did this to her and put them away.
But, ma'am, I cannot do it without you.
I need you.
Phoebe needs you.
What exactly do you need from me?
A second chance.
A second chance
to make this right.
And, legally...
I need a DNA sample.
A simple swab, ma'am, just a simple swab...
...to confirm, in fact, that you are Phoebe's mother.
That's what you want?
Yes, ma'am.
That's what you want?
Yes, ma'am.
Put a cotton swab in my mouth
to prove I'm her mother?
Yes.
That's what's gonna solve this?
Mm.
This conversation is over. Leave us alone!
CHAVEZ: LVPD's 1982 case file.
Photography canvass of the site.
Eyewitness statement.
Site map of where the shooting took place. The end.
I'm sorry, is that it? Just a few pages?
Site photos of buildings, a handful of sketches,
and one witness statement?
Max is dead serious about our approach.
We're gonna do what they didn't.
But any old evidence, we have to bring back to life,
whether we can get the mother to help us out or not.
Okay, so...
says here "single gunshot wound."
I don't think so.
I think there were two gunshots.
Second gunshot killed Phoebe.
First one missed.
GREG: If this pencil is our trajectory rod,
the bullet skimmed Phoebe's temple
and shot right through the barrette.
That's two gunshots.
That's twice as much info as LVPD had back then.
Gives us a puncher's chance
to learn something about the shooter.
Height, handedness, maybe even a general sense
about the weapon involved.
Let's put this scene on its feet.
RAJAN: Okay, so,
according to Mrs. Williams' original statement,
she and Phoebe left the Plymouth Baptist church
for this bus stop.
She said that they were approached
from the northwest corner, right there.
I'm the gunman.
Give me a sec to be multiple heights.
Oompa Loompa to Yao Ming.
No.
No, this doesn't-- These angles don't make any sense.
You're right.
To get that scrape on the temple,
it's almost like...
it's almost like Phoebe would have to be
taller than the shooter.
Let me stand her up on the bench.
She's a kid. She's bored waiting for the bus.
FOLSOM: Oh, yes.
Does that help
our height issue?
RAJAN: Yeah.
Folsom, how tall are our three shooters?
From here, the killer is five-foot-eight.
Red laser. Back it up some...
Six foot. Green laser.
Back it up even more,
six-foot-four. Blue laser.
Without knowing the type of gun
and the exact position the killer was standing at
40 years ago,
it's impossible to determine height.
Wait a minute.
That building.
What about the building?
That apartment building wasn't there in 1982.
And that building on the far corner.
I mean, back then,
it would've been a bunch of metal and wood.
It would've been a spiderweb for catching errant bullets.
The bullet didn't stop there.
It hit that office building over there.
With any luck,
the bullet could be lodged in the walls somewhere.
Guys, we're close here, all right? More-more-more smoke.
Let's play laser tag over here.
Order of magnitude.
It's close enough. Set up for the mean average.
Six feet.
Hmm.
Hang on, gents.
Allie's getting into heavy metal.
Scratch that. Now, she's getting into the blues. No bullet.
Hey, do you still have those photos from earlier?
The-the one with the damaged barrette.
You see how the metal from the barrette is twisted to the left?
The projectile might've redirected,
like fingers tipping a field goal.
So, I'm thinking they need to start looking
a smidge more to the right.
Hey, guys,
we need to redirect the angle, like,
three or four degrees to the right
and a good half a foot higher.
FINADO: Here.
There we go.
Guys?
Any luck?
Yeah.
Big progress.
With a bullet.
All my sledgehammering's going to cost the city
a pretty penny.
Please tell me we found something probative
from that bullet.
I wish I could. The striation marks
have been severely damaged,
and even if we had the gun in question,
this'll never hold up.
You're telling me we found a miracle bullet,
41 years after the fact, and... nothing?
Not exactly nothing. We know the killer was about six-four.
And you see those shiny crystals
along the jagged tip of the projectile?
Well, I took the liberty of grinding a few
of Phoebe's rhinestones from her barrette into a fine powder.
Blingo. It was a match to the bullet.
At least we know. The bullet you found was the first shot
fired at Phoebe Williams.
Okay. What about the second shot?
Thought I told you to leave us alone.
Yes, ma'am, you did, but I'm a little hardheaded.
And I have some new information, ma'am. Some...
I'll put some coffee on.
Last picture I ever took of her was her coloring.
She would wear some crayons out.
When she was real little, I asked her,
"Phoebe, what color is your favorite?"
Mm-hmm.
"Phoebe, what color is your favorite?"
Mm-hmm.
You know what she told me? "Mama, I can't answer that.
It would hurt the other colors' feelings."
Mm. Mm.
Hmm.
Things you remember.
Now, what's this business about you have new information?
Okay, ma'am.
I've got some photos of my own.
So we believe that there were two shots fired.
The first one
we pulled from a building near the church.
I'd like to show you a picture of Phoebe's skull.
There is a bone scrape right above her right temple.
we believe the first shot fired grazed her face,
and then damaged her barrette.
May I?
You think you know what happened.
I was there.
Phoebe and I
used to sell jewelry and handcrafts for the church.
We were raising money for a mission trip.
I think you earned this.
Now I can buy that Humpty Dumpty book for Sharise.
Give me the money!
RAQUEL: This kid with a gun
wanted our money box.
I gave him a piece of my mind.
I wasn't gonna let some evil boy
take the good Lord's money.
I could see the Devil in his eyes.
And the fear.
(screams): Mommy!
I am so sorry, Mrs. Williams,
but we haven't found that second bullet.
And you'll never find it, never in a hundred years.
Why do you say that?
'Cause I have it.
The through-and-through went into you.
Phoebe died trying to save my life.
I guess you could say
I carry this bullet
close to my heart.
How far would you go
to find the people that did this to you and your daughter?
All the way.
I need that bullet.
That bullet is the only evidence that can help us solve this.
When a... when a shot is fired, it leaves grooves
on the bullet, right?
Those grooves, ma'am, they tell a tale.
A tale that could lead us back to the person who did that.
If the doctors say that it will still compromise your health,
we don't have to do it.
Choice is up to you.
Mother to mother, let me ask you something.
Yes, ma'am.
If you were carrying this lead in your chest,
and you needed it to avenge the death of your boy,
what would you do?
I think we both know the answer to that.
If you don't want to do this,
we can just call this whole thing off.
Don't you worry about me dying, Ms. Roby.
One might say I died 41 years ago.
Mm-mm.
You're strong.
I'm not trying to be strong.
I need something from you.
Name it.
I don't have anyone.
Widowed, no brother, sister, next of kin.
All I got is this crooked old walking stick
and faded memories of my girl.
If something was to happen...
I'm listening.
...bury my child...
in her rightful state.
I want you
to make me that promise.
I promise.
Hey.
A little light reading?
Yeah. It's that child's case. Please.
Thank you for meeting me.
I can't stay long, I've got to get back to the hospital.
We don't have to eat.
Are you ready to order?
Hi.
Single malt neat. Make it a double.
Mm. That bad? (chuckles)
I'm leaving. I'm leaving you to your own world.
I don't belong here.
I thought I could unscramble scrambled eggs, but I can't.
(quietly): Wow.
I've had...
I've had a day.
I just convinced this woman
to have this life-threatening surgery
where they're gonna remove this bullet
that might not solve the murder.
Bad timing.
It's never a good time to say goodbye.
If it doesn't end bad,
sometimes it just doesn't end, Max.
Yeah, no truer words.
I'll always be here for you
and for our son when it counts, always.
I know.
But all the king's horses and all the king's men.
We both know how the rest goes.
Here you go.
♪ ♪
Mom.
How'd you know?
I got you on my phone so I always know where you are.
My boy. My baby.
Maxine Roby?
Mrs. Williams will see you now.
Hi.
Go get the man.
♪ ♪
It's nearly midnight. Please tell me you're close.
I'm just comparing striation marks between
the mangled bullet that you found
and Mrs. Williams' bullet,
and I can't believe the difference. Look.
The bullet from Mrs. Williams
is in pristine condition.
Yeah, that makes sense.
is in pristine condition.
Yeah, that makes sense.
After it entered her chest, the body would have treated it
like a foreign object.
Tissue wraps around it, protects it,
like a warm blanket.
Lucky for us.
I'm running the striation marks through NIBIN,
but I can already tell you we now know
the type of bullet used: it's a .45 ACP.
Automatic Colt Pistol?
Standard issue, military grade. Full metal jacket.
Most likely fired from a government-issue
Remington Rand M1911A1 pistol from World War II.
So we're looking for a military man from World War II?
Didn't Mrs. Williams claim that the shooter was a teenager?
Someone from World War II would be nearly 100 years old.
Might be looking for a gun collector.
Hey.
Who told you all to stay late?
ALL: Folsom.
FOLSOM: The gun that killed Phoebe was used in a liquor store
robbery in 1961.
It went unsolved.
I thought Mrs. Williams said a teenager did the shooting.
She did. Okay, so now we are looking for
two crimes, one gun, and two different perps, right?
The prime suspect in this old case was Matthew Beck.
He died in 1973, but his name, his name lives on, right?
You're thinking a family member?
Son of a gunman.
RAJAN: This is insane.
19 children and grandchildren.
So we could door-knock all these people, right?
One of 'em is bound to know
who granddaddy left all his guns to, or I don't know.
Hold on.
I-I've seen this guy before.
I know I have.
You all have.
Oh, my God, of course.
Oh, my God, of course who?
...skiers didn't pull me and the barrel.
I got all tangled up down there. It was spooky.
Are you kidding me?
One thing we know for sure,
killers do return to the crime scene
to get rid of evidence.
41 years after the fact.
His dad was a suspect in a related gun crime.
Will that be enough, or...
GREG: I spy something new,
something damning,
something blue.
Screen-grab that net pouch.
Go tighter.
Penny. Penny!
PENNY: Blue license plate.
ROBY: Run it through the DMV database.
Pickup truck.
Las Vegas area code 702.
PARK: Registered to Jeremiah Beck.
CHAVEZ: Scuba Steve.
He was right under our nose the entire time.
And just like a guilty prize fighter, he took a dive.
Oh, that was forever ago.
I was a teenager,
a salt mine company was hiring.
I think I worked there for about half a summer.
CHAVEZ: Six weeks, to be exact.
Until you were fired for theft.
And according to your disciplinary files,
you were taking barrels and then recycling them for cash, so...
Not that they weren't all stamped "Salt Mine Co."
Rifle, Glock, nine-mil, Glock,
and Remington Rand 1911A1. (clicks tongue)
ROBY: So let me tell you how this is gonna go.
My team's gonna head back to the crime lab.
We're going to dust
every one of those weapons for prints.
And my guess is yours will be all over
that World War II relic.
So we're gonna test-fire it...
...and we're gonna compare the striation marks
on the bullet that we recovered
to the ones fired by your gun.
Your second shot killed the girl in cold blood.
You were going to get rid of the bodies...
...but an eyewitness scared you off
before you even realized Mrs. Williams was still alive.
And then when you dumped the body,
you didn't know how heavy a 65-pound girl
could be in a metal drum.
The water levels at Lake Mead hit record lows,
and so did you.
You had to get rid of the evidence,
and you ended up wearing it on the local news.
Hands behind your back.
Hey. Where you off to?
Desert Palms.
I owe Mrs. Williams a visit.
Ma'am, visiting hours are over.
Yeah, but where's Mrs. Williams?
♪ No, I never felt like I belonged here ♪
No.
♪ This world wasn't quite ready for me ♪
♪ Whoever's out there in the stratosphere ♪
♪ Got a question for the cosmic engineer ♪
♪ Is it all you believed it would be? ♪
♪ Hey, God, why don't you take me home? ♪
Looks like you didn't miss the art show after all.
♪ So we might as well blast off today ♪
♪ For fun ♪
♪ I'm waiting on my spaceship to come ♪
♪ How much pain can we bear being human? ♪
♪ I'm pretty sure that my mission is done here ♪
♪ How much more do you want from me? ♪
♪ Haven't I earned the right to be a nominee? ♪
♪ To float out past the Pleiades ♪
♪ Oh, no, you can't be that hard to please ♪
♪ Hey, God, why don't you take me home? ♪
♪ Beam me up, I got a ticket to board ♪
♪ Yeah, you know I'm coming home anyway ♪
♪ So we might as well blast off today ♪
♪ For fun ♪
♪ I'm waiting on my spaceship to come ♪
♪ Waiting on my spaceship to come ♪
♪ Oh, whoa ♪
♪ Waiting on my spaceship ♪
♪ To come. ♪
Captioning sponsored by CBS
and TOYOTA.
Captioned by Media Access Group at WGBH access.wgbh.org